Open Problems in History
← All problems

When did the thylacine go extinct in the wild?

The last known thylacine died in a Hobart zoo in September 1936, but whether the species survived in the Tasmanian bush into the 1940s, the 1980s or later remains disputed.

Chronology · Pacific · 1888–2019digitizationscience

Could use help from statisticians and data scientists, archivists and librarians, geneticists and GIS specialists.

Thylacine at Beaumaris Zoo, Hobart, photographed by Ben Sheppard
Thylacine at Beaumaris Zoo, Hobart, photographed by Ben Sheppard. Ben Sheppard, Public domain

Recent work

last moved Aug 2025
2016’162017’172018’182019’192020’202021’212022’222023’232024’242025’252026’26
  1. Aug 2025Paper
    Illuminating the mystery of thylacine extinction: a role for relaxed selection and gene lossB. G. Salve and N. Vijay · Proceedings of the Royal Society BIdentifies ancient gene losses in the thylacine genome and asks whether they increased vulnerability, bearing on causes rather than the date.
  2. Nov 2024Tool
    Inferring species extinction from sighting dataR. S. McCrea, T. Cheale, E. Campillo-Funollet and D. L. Roberts · Cambridge Prisms: ExtinctionReview of sighting-record extinction methods and their assumptions, with an RShiny application implementing several of them.
  3. Apr 2024Data
    Five previously undescribed thylacine (Thylacinus cynocephalus) specimens held in the museums of the University of MelbourneR. Long · Australian ZoologistDescribes five skulls accessioned between 1893 and 1932, showing that university teaching collections still hold uncatalogued specimens.
  4. Dec 2023Data
    The Tasmanian Thylacine Sighting Record Database (TTSRD): 1,223 quality-rated and geo-located Thylacine observations from 1910 to 2019B. W. Brook, S. R. Sleightholme, C. R. Campbell, I. Jarić and J. C. Buettel · Australian ZoologistDescribes the deduplicated, dated, geo-tagged and quality-rated sighting database, each record linked to an image of its source.Advances the problem
  5. Oct 2023Paper
    How collections and reputation were built out of Tasmanian violence: thylacines (Thylacinus cynocephalus) and Aboriginal remains from Morton Allport (1830–1878)J. Ashby · Archives of Natural HistoryPlaces the colonial trade in thylacine specimens alongside the trade in Aboriginal remains, shaping how museum records of the species should be read.
  6. May 2023Paper
    The discovery of the remains of the last Tasmanian tiger (Thylacinus cynocephalus)R. Paddle and K. Medlock · Australian ZoologistIdentifies the skin and skeleton of the aged female that died on 7 September 1936 in the Tasmanian Museum's collection.
  7. Mar 2023Paper
    Resolving when (and where) the Thylacine went extinctB. W. Brook, S. R. Sleightholme, C. R. Campbell, I. Jarić and J. C. Buettel · Science of the Total EnvironmentHigh-quality records imply extinction in the 1940s to 1970s; modelling all 1,237 records allows the late 1980s to early 2000s.Advances the problem
  8. Mar 2023Paper
    Thylacine: The History, Ecology and Loss of the Tasmanian TigerB. Holmes and G. Linnard (eds.) · CSIRO PublishingEdited volume on the thylacine's history and ecology, including a chapter on the bounty years from 1830 to 1914.
  9. Jan 2021Paper
    Resolving when (and where) the Thylacine went extinctB. W. Brook et al. · bioRxivPreprint whose suggestion of possible survival into the late twentieth century drew wide press coverage two years before formal publication.
  10. Dec 2020Paper
    The parson, the psychiatrist, the publican, and his nephews: the two final thylacine captures in TasmaniaG. Linnard, M. Williams and B. Holmes · Papers and Proceedings of the THRAArgues from council minutes and film evidence that the last captive thylacines were snared in the north-west around 1930.
  11. Sep 2020Data
    A Catalogue of the Thylacine captured on filmS. R. Sleightholme and C. R. Campbell · Australian ZoologistThylacine Image Registry of 112 known photographs with corrected provenance, the reference set for judging any new photographic claim.
  12. May 2020Data
    Footage of a Beaumaris Zoo thylacine from the 1935 travelogue Tasmania the Wonderland identified at the NFSAB. Holmes, G. Linnard and M. Williams · National Film and Sound Archive / Australian GeographicReleased as the latest known moving images of a living thylacine, filmed about 18 months before the last captive death.
  13. Oct 2019Data
    Right to Information release lists eight thylacine sightings reported to the department since 2016DPIPWE (Tasmania) · news coverageReleased reports from the Huon, Corinna, Waratah, Mt Roland and elsewhere; the department said none had been confirmed.
  14. Jun 2019Tool
    A fast re-sampling method for using reliability ratings of sightings with extinction-date estimatorsB. W. Brook, J. C. Buettel and I. Jarić · EcologyRe-sampling method and R script that let any extinction-date estimator use graded sightings, validated on species of known fate.
  15. Sep 2018Data
    The International Thylacine Specimen Database (6th Revision - Project Summary & Final Report)S. R. Sleightholme and C. R. Campbell · Australian ZoologistFinal report on the worldwide catalogue of surviving thylacine specimens, the reference list for any search for late-dated physical evidence.
  16. Aug 2018Paper
    Deficiencies in estimating the extinction date of the thylacine with mixed certainty dataB. W. Brook, S. R. Sleightholme, C. R. Campbell and J. C. Buettel · Conservation BiologyArgues that reporting biases make it premature to place extinction soon after the last captive animal died.
  17. Aug 2018Paper
    Reevaluating sighting models and moving beyond them to test and contextualize the extinction of the thylacineC. J. Carlson, A. L. Bond and K. R. Burgio · Conservation BiologyReply defending the original analysis and its conclusion that survival into recent decades is implausible.
  18. Feb 2018Paper
    Estimating the extinction date of the thylacine with mixed certainty dataC. J. Carlson, A. L. Bond and K. R. Burgio · Conservation BiologyMost likely extinction date 1940, with other estimators between 1936 and 1943 and none later than 1956.Advances the problem
  19. Jan 2018Field & lab
    High-quality fossil dates support a synchronous, Late Holocene extinction of devils and thylacines in mainland AustraliaL. C. White, F. Saltré, C. J. A. Bradshaw and J. J. Austin · Biology LettersRadiocarbon dates place mainland extinction in the Late Holocene, the baseline against which claimed mainland sightings are judged.
  20. Dec 2017Field & lab
    Genome of the Tasmanian tiger provides insights into the evolution and demography of an extinct marsupial carnivoreC. Y. Feigin et al. · Nature Ecology & EvolutionGenome from a preserved museum pouch young showed low diversity and a long-term decline beginning well before human arrival.
  21. Apr 2017Paper
    Estimating the extinction date of the thylacine accounting for unconfirmed sightingsC. J. Carlson, A. L. Bond and K. R. Burgio · bioRxivPreprint of the Bayesian mixed-certainty analysis that placed extinction most likely around 1940.
  22. Mar 2017Event
    James Cook University announces camera-trap search for thylacines on Cape YorkS. Abell and W. Laurance (James Cook University) · JCU media releaseSurvey prompted by reported mainland sightings; no thylacine detections have been published from it.
  23. Dec 2016Data
    Tasmanian wildlife department releases redacted thylacine witness statements dating back to 2001DPIPWE (Tasmania) · The ExaminerFirst public release of the department's recent sighting file, with names, locations and photographs redacted.

Compiled by Claude Opus 5.5, 2026-10-12

Why it matters

The thylacine is the standard example of a historically documented mammal extinction caused by colonial persecution, and its date bears on how historians weigh the government bounty of 1888 to 1909, private bounties from the 1830s, habitat change and possible disease. Whether it vanished by the 1940s or lingered into the 1980s also decides whether the protection granted in 1936 and the reserves of the 1960s and 1970s came too late by years or by decades. Beyond Tasmania, it is the main test case for methods that infer extinction dates from a mix of specimens and unverified sightings, which conservation bodies use to declare species extinct.

Why it is open

Absence leaves no document, so the evidence after 1930 consists almost entirely of sightings, whose reliability is hard to judge and which continued every year through the twentieth century. Estimates therefore depend on which reports are admitted: , Bond and Burgio (2018) put the most likely date near 1940, while Brook and colleagues (2023), using a larger graded database, found that the full record allows extinction as late as the 1980s to early 2000s. Even the anchoring events are contested: the last confirmed wild kill is usually given as Wilf Batty's at Mawbanna in 1930, and (2023) and , Williams and Holmes (2020) disagree about when and where the last captive animals were taken.

What would count as a solution

A public, versioned database of all post-1910 thylacine records with a reliability grading that has been validated against reports of known accuracy, together with an extinction-date estimate whose credible interval and sensitivity to that grading are reported; or physical evidence such as a specimen, DNA from a securely dated sample, or a verified photograph that moves the last confirmed date. The most likely outcome is a credible interval rather than a single year.

Potential approach

  • The human literature gives the baselines: (1985) and (2000) on bounties, decline and the 1930s; (2015) on post-1900 range; and the sighting compilations behind , Bond and Burgio (2018) and Brook and colleagues (2023), whose Tasmanian Thylacine Sighting Record Database lists 1,223 rated records from 1910 to 2019.
  • Teams could text-mine 's digitized Tasmanian newspapers and transcribe the wildlife-service sighting files held by and the , matching each report to existing database entries to find unrecorded sightings and duplicates, and recording who saw what, where and in what conditions.
  • Reliability grading should be made explicit and repeatable: a coding scheme applied by several independent coders, with agreement measured, and calibrated on comparable reports of animals whose presence is known, such as sightings of foxes or quolls later confirmed or refuted.
  • Extinction-date estimators, including the (1993) family and the re-sampling method of Brook, Buettel and Jarić (2019), should first be tested on species with known extinction or rediscovery dates, as (2003) did for the dodo, before results are reported for the thylacine with their sensitivity to grading and to observer effort.
  • An independent check needs field scientists: environmental DNA sampling and camera-trap surveys in the south-western wilderness, where Brook and colleagues (2023) left a small chance of late persistence, and DNA and radiocarbon testing of any hair, scat or skin samples with a post-1930 provenance.

Drafted by Claude Opus 5.5, 2026-10-12

Who can help

statisticians and data scientists
Test extinction-date estimators that use graded sightings on species with known extinction or rediscovery dates, and report how the thylacine estimate shifts with each grading scheme.
archivists and librarians
Identify and list the Tasmanian Archives, wildlife-service and museum files holding post-1910 thylacine reports, bounty payments and zoo records, and prioritize the undigitized series for scanning.
geneticists
Design an environmental DNA survey of the south-western Tasmanian wilderness with stated detection limits, and test whether dated post-1930 hair, scat or skin samples contain thylacine DNA.
GIS specialists
Geolocate every graded sighting against road, track, settlement and land-clearance layers by decade, so that apparent refugia can be separated from where observers happened to be.

Drafted by Claude Opus 5.5, 2026-10-12

Existing work

  1. 1966
    Eric R. Guiler, In Pursuit of the Thylacine, Oryx 8 (5): 307–310.Report on the government-funded search begun in 1963 after an animal was reportedly killed by accident in 1961; it found no confirmed thylacines.
  2. 1985
    Eric R. Guiler, Thylacine: The Tragedy of the Tasmanian Tiger, Melbourne: Oxford University Press.First book-length history of the thylacine's decline, using bounty returns and arguing that disease in the early twentieth century compounded hunting.
  3. 1993
    Andrew R. Solow, Inferring Extinction from Sighting Data, Ecology 74 (3): 962–964.Statistical test for whether a species is extinct given a record of sightings, the basis of most later extinction-date estimators.
  4. 2000
    Robert Paddle, The Last Tasmanian Tiger: The History and Extinction of the Thylacine, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Historical study of attitudes, bounties, zoo keeping and the 1930s, arguing that colonial persecution and neglect, not an inevitable decline, caused the extinction.
  5. 2003
    David L. Roberts and Andrew R. Solow, When did the dodo become extinct?, Nature 426: 245.Applied an optimal linear estimation method to the dodo's last sightings, the model for dating historical extinctions from sparse records.
  6. 2013
    Thomas A. A. Prowse, Christopher N. Johnson, Robert C. Lacy, Corey J. A. Bradshaw, John P. Pollak, Michael J. Watts and Barry W. Brook, No need for disease: testing extinction hypotheses for the thylacine using multi-species metamodels, Journal of Animal Ecology 82 (2): 355–364.Population models including settlers' effects on the prey base reproduced the decline without an epidemic, against the disease hypothesis.
  7. 2015
    Stephen R. Sleightholme and Cameron R. Campbell, A retrospective assessment of 20th century thylacine populations, Australian Zoologist 38 (1): 102–129.Mapped 1,167 geo-referenced captures, kills and confirmed sightings from 1900 to 1940 and discussed possible survival into the 1940s and beyond.
  8. 2017
    Charles Y. Feigin, Axel H. Newton, Liliya Doronina et al., Genome of the Tasmanian tiger provides insights into the evolution and demography of an extinct marsupial carnivore, Nature Ecology & Evolution 2 (1): 182–192.Genome from a museum pouch young indicated low genetic diversity and a long decline beginning well before people reached Australia.
  9. 2018
    Colin J. Carlson, Alexander L. Bond and Kevin R. Burgio, Estimating the extinction date of the thylacine with mixed certainty data, Conservation Biology 32 (2): 477–483.Bayesian model treating valid and invalid sightings as separate processes gave a most likely extinction date of 1940 and none later than 1956.
  10. 2018
    Barry W. Brook, Stephen R. Sleightholme, Cameron R. Campbell and Jessie C. Buettel, Deficiencies in estimating the extinction date of the thylacine with mixed certainty data, Conservation Biology 32 (5): 1195–1197.Critique arguing that reporting biases make it premature to place extinction soon after 1936; answered by Carlson and colleagues in the same issue.
  11. 2019
    Barry W. Brook, Jessie C. Buettel and Ivan Jarić, A fast re-sampling method for using reliability ratings of sightings with extinction-date estimators, Ecology 100 (9): e02787.Method that samples sightings with probability equal to their reliability rating, tested on rediscovered and confirmed-extinct species, with R code.
  12. 2020
    Gareth Linnard, Mike Williams and Branden Holmes, The parson, the psychiatrist, the publican, and his nephews: the two final thylacine captures in Tasmania, Papers and Proceedings of the Tasmanian Historical Research Association 67 (3): 6–22.Archival and film evidence arguing that the last captive thylacines were snared in the north-west around 1930, not in the Florentine Valley in 1933.
  13. 2023
    Barry W. Brook, Stephen R. Sleightholme, Cameron R. Campbell, Ivan Jarić and Jessie C. Buettel, Resolving when (and where) the Thylacine went extinct, Science of the Total Environment 877: 162878.From 1,237 records since 1910, high-quality reports implied extinction in the 1940s to 1970s, but modelling the whole record allowed the late 1980s to early 2000s.
  14. 2023
    Robert Paddle and Kathryn Medlock, The discovery of the remains of the last Tasmanian tiger (Thylacinus cynocephalus), Australian Zoologist 43 (1): 97–108.Zoo and museum archives identified the animal that died on 7 September 1936 as an aged female whose skin and skeleton survive at the Tasmanian Museum.
  15. 2023
    Barry W. Brook, Stephen R. Sleightholme, Cameron R. Campbell, Ivan Jarić and Jessie C. Buettel, The Tasmanian Thylacine Sighting Record Database (TTSRD): 1,223 quality-rated and geo-located Thylacine observations from 1910 to 2019, Australian Zoologist 43 (3): 419–435.Describes the curated, dated, geo-tagged and quality-rated sighting database drawn from archives, newspapers, museum files and private collections.

Archives and collections

  • Tasmanian Archives (Libraries Tasmania), Hobartpartly digitized Government thylacine bounty payments 1888–1909; Van Diemen's Land Company records for Woolnorth; Beaumaris Zoo and Hobart City Council reserves committee papers; photographsHolds Van Diemen's Land Company station records, government administrative series that should include bounty payment records, and municipal zoo papers; some series are imaged in the online viewer, many are not, and the bounty series still need precise identification.
  • Trove, National Library of Australia, Canberradigitized Digitized Australian newspapers, including the Tasmanian pressSearchable OCR text of the Mercury, Examiner, Advocate and other papers that carried reports of kills, captures and sightings; OCR quality varies and spelling variants such as 'tiger' and 'hyena' must be searched.
  • Department of Natural Resources and Environment Tasmania (NRE Tasmania), Hobartnot digitized Parks and Wildlife Service and successor-department thylacine sighting files and witness statementsHolds sighting reports and witness statements logged by the state wildlife service; redacted lists of reports since 2001 were released in 2016 and 2019, and fuller access is by Right to Information request.
  • Tasmanian Museum and Art Gallery, Hobartpartly digitized Zoology collection: thylacine skins, skeletons and registers, including the remains of the animal that died at Beaumaris Zoo in 1936; museum annual reportsSpecimens and unpublished museum records used by (2023); any later-dated tissue would be the obvious material for DNA and radiocarbon testing.
  • International Thylacine Specimen Databasepartly digitized Catalogue and photographs of surviving thylacine specimens worldwide (6th revision, 2018)Compiled by Stephen and Cameron Campbell; few specimens carry a recorded date and place of collection, which limits its use for dating the last wild animals.
  • Atlas of Living Australiadigitized Occurrence records for Thylacinus cynocephalus from museum and survey datasetsAggregated specimen and occurrence records with collection dates where known, useful for cross-checking the last dated physical evidence.

Compiled by Claude Opus 5.5, 2026-10-12

Comments